Question – Is Process Physics a successful theory?
‘I looked up Process Physics and learned that it perhaps has not achieved “spectacular success.” Professor Cahill seems to be one of the few who wholeheartedly embrace the ideas.’
Question – Why the need for Process Physics ?
QM has proved a remarkably accurate tool for making mathematical predictions about the behaviour of sub-atomic particles but it does not have a plausible ontology associated with it ie it offers no useful or credible concept about the nature of reality.
GR also produces accurate results and predictions – most of the time. There are, however, several observed effects that Relativity says should not happen (e.g the measured speed of galaxy rotation at the edges). This is of course the ultimate fail for any scientific theory. Dark Matter has been postulated to account for the ‘missing’ gravity required to explain the anomalous behaviour. But the Universe is expanding and the DM would stop that, so another patch, Dark Energy has been invented to push against the DM. Problem is we can’t interact with or detect either. Even if one accepted the reasonableness of such extraordinary fixes, there is a further inherent problem – although the amounts of DE and DM are conveniently postulated to allow for observed acceleration, that ratio won’t work as the universe further expands and Gravity weakens. It seems remarkable that scientific consensus would rather believe that the universe is composed of 95% of stuff we can’t look at or measure, than admit that there must be a problem in a theory if it requires these numbers to hold it up.
BUT….a real problem is that QM and GR have completely incompatible approaches. If you feed QM assumptions into GR (or other way round – can’t remember) you get ‘infinite’ energies, that are nonsensical. QM assumes matter is discrete (quanta, particles) and GR assumes it is smooth and continuous, an incompatibility producing lots of problems at the interface, Big Bang for instance, how to transition, which is right etc etc.
All this is widely documented by several commentator’s eg at a conference releasing a ‘map of dark matter’ in 2012, a Dr Heymans conceded:
‘It’s very widely believed that our final understanding of the ‘dark universe’ is going to have to invoke some new physics, something that will forever change our view of the Universe.’
Prof Cahill has solved all this with a highly appealing ontology that incorporates a constructive theory of gravity for good measure. He accounts for all observations (mathematically) without DM and DE, and has made various predictions (eg temperature at the centre of the sun) that differ from current thinking and hopefully will be testable, as well as reconciling QM and GR.
A lot of this stuff is in MINDFIELD in one way or another.
Question – Is MindField a Science Thriller?
The fact that Process Physics is fringe-y is not necessarily a problem for your book, but I’ll need to know that for MindField to be considered a Science Thriller, it is not just science fiction. When discussing extreme physics, the distinction is hard to tell, but whatever technical discussion appears in MindField must have plenty of “real” physics in it.
The problem I encountered is less to do with SF (though I’ll discuss that one below) but how to balance scientific exposition with narrative pace. The history of my editing is I have had to ‘kill my babies’ by progressively removing chunks of ‘science-y’ discourse or philosophising, because readers warned me I was losing them (as in ‘losing their interest’).
I believe I have left enough science in to explain the plot and satisfy the interested (perhaps to provoke the curious to further investigation) and to make the central theme of the book plausible.
There is also a major role given to a re-run of the Michelson Morley experiment of 1887 (one of the most famous ever and absolutely crucial – the reason Einstein developed Relativity was because this experiment was held to prove light had one speed for all observers) and a bunch of techno stuff from spying on the net to how to run networks to maximise share trading profits (one day it will happen and I won’t make a penny from it!!) This may become the interest that propels PP into the limelight.
In the Guardian newspaper on 1st May 2014 I read:
‘Michael Lewis discusses his new book Flash Boys an investigation into high-frequency trading. He describes how big investment banks take advantage of minute differences in share prices and internet connections speeds to skim billions of dollars from stock-market trading without taking any real risk.
I’ve invented a scientific experiment too which would measure if gravity can travel faster than the speed of light. This would nail the PP v GR rivalry in one go (it isn’t going to happen though as it requires exploding a lot of Atom bombs in space).
Question – So is MindField Science Fiction?
I don’t believe it is, though I take your point that the distinction can be fuzzy. There is discussion (and an example at the end) of how time might act in an apparently non-sequential way (explained in detail below).
A huge part of physics is about the relationship of time and space (position and velocity). Modern physics doesn’t do ‘time’ well – there is nothing in physics to establish the direction of time (you can have a ‘plus’ or a ‘minus’ value in its equations) so to try to write this in, there is a circular argument derived from the study of heating gases (Entropy and the Second Law of thermodynamics). I hope I’m not treading on any toes when I say I always had the sense they were waffling.
Relativity compounds this by dismissing the ‘now’ as a psychological illusion by claiming equal value to all futures and histories in relation to all of space as ‘space-time’. Again – if nothing else – not a satisfying correspondence to what we experience (though some obfuscators justify space-time because of its obscurity).
PP has a completely different approach. It says the only ‘quality’ that can’t be defined in terms of anything else is ‘time’ and that simultaneity exists across the universe.
Of course, necessarily, science is all about speculation of how things might work. For instance: the Astronomer Royal speaks quite seriously of parallel universes and string theorists postulate hidden dimensions of space (lots of them), again in complete seriousness.
There is also a great tradition of speculation about time:
Feynman concluded time ran backwards sub-atomically (I think I’m right but that needs checking) and Kurt Godel’s work (see below) with Relativity suggested you can travel into the past (at least in theory) – though I wonder if that was more a critique of Relativity than anything else. Einstein is said to have joined Princeton so as he could take walks with Godel and for me he represents a ‘heroic’ figure, though he starved himself to death when his wife died because he thought everyone else was trying to poison him – so he was not without flaws!
I’ve already mentioned Dark Energy and Dark Matter. It’s a batty world out there so I’m not too embarrassed to join with the speculation; which I do in this way:
My thesis is a progressive reasoning that there is a possibility of loops in time, set in the real world. It uses an aspect of PP called Self-Referential Noise ( the element in PP that gives time inherent anisotropy – see below) combined with the possibility of this SRN resembling a Modular form (like the rotation of a square where you end up where you started). It isn’t time travel but there is the suggestion that time might not run sequentially and you might (through chance – or a random occurrence) re-run an interval you have already experienced. There is a bit of philosophising that you might not even know it if you had (complete parallel with Godel’s work on Relativity) though certain pointers could leave hints. I also give consideration to why one would even make the suggestion of loops in the first place (surprisingly a lot of scope here!!!) These are my hidden dimensions in time.
Time travel is annoying because it’s cheating – an implausible device used for literary convenience – a get out of jail free card. I think my novel is very unusual in providing a plausible explanation of how the appearance of non-sequential time might operate (even of how ‘paranormal’ phenomena might appear) whilst insisting that only the ‘now’ is real and that any of these ‘effects’ can only occur in the ‘now’.
All this is flagged virtually from page one – though the reader would not know it till later.
Question – What is Process Physics?
After reading a few paragraphs online, I have no idea what Process Physics is.
Conventionally in science we (as in ‘humans’) make observations, form a theory about what’s happening and test it against experiments with further observation. If it is not falsified we then claim we have an explanation. Certain ‘biggies’ we say are rules of nature and assert that they are immutable and universal – in other words – this is how it works.
PP has a completely different approach, it has a ’suck and see’ origin.
There is a lot of philosophy behind this, starting with Godel’s Incompleteness Theorem, flagged in the opening para of my book. Basically he showed that within any reasonably complex logical system there are things that are true that can’t be proved. The implication being that however sophisticated conventional science becomes there will always be (must always be) something popping out that conventional science can’t explain. Extraordinary stuff – means Math can never be regarded as complete. To be clear, this is not fringe in any way. Godel has been compared to Aristotle in his contribution to philosophy.
PP tries to dive under that radar by taking a series of relationships and running them stochastically (round and round in computer iterations) to see what evolves. There is a history of this approach eg fractals, Stephen Wolfram (see Ted talks) and no doubt many more including, I expect, weather forecasting. It’s a very different way of representing a complex system and well removed from the mechanistic determinism that derives from Newtonian mechanics that most (many? don’t know) scientists still regard as the only legitimate way to approach a problem.
Of course, the equation you run must not be arbitrary. In PP it was derived via the following (historic) progression
1) Schrodinger’s Equation from QM,
2) Feynman path integral formalism to establish eigenvalue solutions to Schrodinger equation
3) Discovery by mathematicians Parisi and Wu that they can reproduce results of Feynman in 2, with a stochastic system with random introduced variable designed to allow computational flexibility for computer modelling (will become Self-Referential Noise – see above)
4), Prof Cahill takes out reference to space in 3) so as relations are completely abstracted ie representing nothing at this stage other than ‘connections’. He does this with the intent of better representing the nature of time. Runs iterator equation to look at results.
5) Neural type network emerges mapping ‘connections’ or abstract ‘relatedness’.
Investigation into properties of evolving neural type network show space like characteristics (cubing of connections with doubling of distance).
Further ‘defects’ appear that linger – equivalent to matter.
Implication is that space is made of stuff and has dynamical effect on interactions – and that matter and space are the same ‘stuff’ with differing properties (space is not just ‘no stuff’ it is ‘different stuff’.)
I’m hazy after this (and it becomes very technical) but the crucial stage of finding a ‘mind-like’ network meets the narrative intention of the novel.
6) Corrections fed into equations to account for dynamical effects of space
7) An ontology became apparent expressed in terms of a quantum foam.
The big differences between Process Physics and Classical Physics are therefore:
Process Physics asserts that:
- Speed of light not fixed (shown by Michelson Morley – the big dispute between Prof Cahill and the rest of the science community (the opening few paras of http://arxiv.org/pdf/physics/0608205.pdf are good on this.)
- Space is made of stuff.
- ‘Suck it and see’ internally derived representation (semantic) rather than looking in with axioms and rules .(syntactic) ie Process v Non-process >Only time (‘now’) is inexpressible in terms of something else.
- PP reconciles QM and GR (in so far as the results of each are derived from PP).
All of this is touched on (without the names of scientists) in my book.
For technical papers go to this site